How to Trust Your Own Taste (and Ignore the Critics)

Do you ever feel like you’re supposed to love a wine just because a critic said so? You nod along at tastings, even when the wine in your glass doesn’t thrill you. Over time, you start to doubt your own palate, letting ratings and opinions dictate what you drink. That pressure steals the joy out of wine.

Here’s the truth: wine is personal. No critic, sommelier, or friend has your palate. You are the only one who can decide what’s good to you. Yet many wine lovers hand over that power to ratings, price tags, or other people’s opinions.

This week, I’ll show you how to take it back. Wine becomes more rewarding when you stop worrying about what others think. Let’s break that habit and focus on what matters—what’s in your glass, and how it makes you feel.

What you'll learn today

• Why outside opinions cloud your judgment
• How to build confidence in your taste
• Simple ways to explore wines on your terms

‍

Why We Doubt Our Own Palates

You probably started drinking wine by trusting labels, reviews, or recommendations. That’s how most of us begin. Over time, this creates an expectation: someone else knows better. Critics, wine shop staff, and even friends can make you feel like there’s a “right” answer about what’s good.

This pressure is strongest in group settings. At a tasting, you might hear people describe flavors you don’t notice. You start to question yourself. Maybe you’re missing something? Maybe your palate isn’t good enough? This is how doubt creeps in.

The problem is, every palate is different. What’s enjoyable to one person might not be to another. Critics taste hundreds of wines a week and have preferences shaped by their own experiences. Their opinion doesn’t have to be your opinion.

When you trust outside voices more than yourself, wine feels less fun. You focus on whether you’re “right” instead of whether you’re enjoying the glass. The goal is to flip that mindset—so you taste for yourself, not for approval.

‍

How to Tune Out External Noise

The first step to trusting your taste is learning to ignore outside influences. Start with reviews. If you’re trying a new wine, don’t read ratings or tasting notes beforehand. They plant ideas in your head. Taste first, then see if you agree.

Labels and prices can also mess with your judgment. A high price doesn’t guarantee you’ll like it more. Cover the label during a tasting and compare it to something less expensive. You might be surprised.

Finally, stop comparing yourself to other tasters. Their notes may be more detailed, but that doesn’t make them right. They’re describing what they experience, not what you should.

Remember, critics and friends have their own palates. They’re tasting through their lens, just like you do. When you remove these outside pressures, you’ll start to notice what you actually enjoy. The wine world is full of noise, but your palate gets clearer when you block it out and focus on the glass in front of you.

‍

Build Confidence in Your Taste

Confidence comes from experience, not permission. The more you taste, the more you learn what you like. Here’s a simple way to start: keep a tasting journal. Write down what you smell and taste in plain language—no need for fancy terms. Note if you enjoyed it and why. A great place to start is with my tasting worksheet, which you can download here.

Next, taste wines side by side. Comparing two or three wines at once makes differences stand out. You’ll quickly notice which styles you prefer. Do this with different regions, grapes, or even vintages of the same wine. You can find a more detailed guide in my article about How Comparative Tasting Builds Real Wine Knowledge.

Revisit wines you’ve had before. Sometimes your opinion changes as your palate grows. A wine you disliked once might surprise you later, or vice versa. Both experiences teach you something.

The goal isn’t to memorize tasting notes. It’s to recognize patterns in what you enjoy. Over time, you’ll see that your palate is consistent. You’ll start to trust it without needing backup from critics or friends. That’s when wine starts to feel natural and fun.

‍

Explore Without Fear

Once you start trusting your palate, you’ll want to try more wines. Don’t limit yourself to what critics praise or what’s popular. Explore regions you’ve never heard of. Try grapes outside the usual lineup. You might find a favorite in an unexpected place.

Take small risks. Buy a bottle from the bargain shelf or an unknown producer. If you love it, great. If you don’t, you’ve only spent a little to learn something valuable. Not every wine needs to be perfect to teach you about your taste.

Some of the best discoveries come from wines that break the “rules.” Maybe it’s a natural wine that critics dismiss, or a cheap bottle that outshines an expensive one. These moments remind you that wine isn’t about status—it’s about enjoyment.

Mistakes will happen. You’ll open bottles you don’t like. That’s okay. Every “miss” is part of the process. The more you explore, the more confident you’ll feel making your own choices—and enjoying them without second-guessing.

‍

Key Takeaway: Trust Yourself

Here’s the bottom line: the only opinion that matters is yours. Critics, friends, and price tags can’t tell you what you enjoy. Only you can.

Trusting your palate doesn’t happen overnight. It takes practice, curiosity, and a willingness to ignore the noise. Start small—taste without reading reviews, keep a journal, and pay attention to your reactions. Over time, you’ll build a clear picture of what you love.

Confidence comes when you stop seeking approval and start tasting for yourself. Wine becomes easier, more fun, and more meaningful when you own your choices.

This week, open a bottle you’ve been curious about. Don’t read the score. Don’t ask for opinions. Taste it and decide for yourself.

The best wine isn’t the one everyone else loves—it’s the one you do.

‍